THE MENNOTAUR

combining the anabaptist theology of the bull with the physical strength of menno simons

Thursday, April 06, 2006

The Gospel of Judas: irrelevant to Christ's mission

As a Christian of the Mennonite tradition (or denomination) the newly discovered Gospel of Judas is not faith-shattering, nor is it a threat to the Church.

similar to the Gospel of Thomas and the Gospel of Mary, the author of the Gospel of Judas is unknown but has similar tones to the gospels accepted in the New Testament. This is why those gospels, including the Gospel of Judas, will not be accepted by the Church. It is not a matter of content, so much as it is a matter of authenticity. The same can be said for the Book of Mormon that the Church of Latter-Day Saints proclaims is another testament of Jesus Christ. No author, and no history within the early church.

While the Gospel of Judas seems interesting it's content would not change the event of the cross and the resurrection, nor the meaning behind it. Furthermore, knowledge of first-century Palestinian culture and the meaning of the order of the disciples at the last supper, indicate that Peter was indeed the closest disciple to Jesus, not Judas.

While the Gospel of Judas paints Judas as a hero (go figure) I would doubt that many Christians see Judas as a despicable character in the New Testament to begin with. If it were not for Judas betraying Jesus, the cross and the resurrection would never have happened! It is also argued, in some Christian theological circles, that if it were not Judas, it would have been a different disciple turning Jesus in. Such action was necessary for the divine plan of God to take place.

As a Mennonite, I believe (as Mennonites do) that Jesus was both fully human and fully divine. That being said, if Jesus did orchestrate his own betrayal, it still would have been God's will since he is God incarnate. Every prophecy within the Old Testament points to Jesus of Nazareth as the messiah. His betrayal is one of them, and just like he asked Peter to carry a sword when he was taken to fulfill the prophecy, he very well have asked Judas to do his part and betray him (without the knowledge of the other disciples) in order to keep in step with OT prophecy. Either way, Jesus still died on the cross for the sins of all who believe in him and was still resurrected from the grave.

Will I read the Gospel of Judas? Sure. I just fail to see how it will change my theology or the Church.